I am making this a public letter. It’s too important not to speak out.
Dear Senator/Representative,
I write to you today as a constituent and a person of faith deeply concerned about the escalating situation involving U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) operations in Minneapolis, Minnesota and the tragic deaths of at least two U.S. citizens during those operations.
Over the past weeks, Minneapolis has witnessed multiple shootings by federal immigration agents — including the killing of 37-year-old Renée Nicole Good on January 7 and, most recently, the fatal shooting of Alex Pretti on January 24, both in circumstances that remain intensely contested. Video evidence and independent analysis raise serious questions about the official narratives that these individuals posed imminent threats when they were killed — questions that demand transparency, accountability, and independent review. Protesters and community members have repeatedly stated that these were citizens exercising their rights to observe and document enforcement activity, not domestic terrorists.
The deployment of thousands of federal immigration agents under Operation Metro Surge — including ICE and Border Patrol personnel — has sparked widespread unrest, legal challenges, and calls from Minnesota leaders for federal de-escalation. In response to these deaths and the mounting tension, many Minnesotans — including business leaders, civil rights advocates, and faith communities — have called for an immediate reduction of federal enforcement presence and for investments in humane, rights-respecting policies that protect both community safety and civil liberties.
From a faith perspective, numerous religious leaders and organizations have spoken prophetically in this moment. The United Methodist Council of Bishops issued a statement condemning the violence as “evil actions perpetuated by governmental authorities” and affirming the sacred worth of every person and the way of peace, urging care for neighbors and a rejection of fear-based tactics. The Episcopal Church leadership in Minnesota has likewise lamented the killing of civilians during federal enforcement operations and called for responses rooted in justice, compassion, and respect for human dignity. These voices remind us that human life is not measured by policy objectives alone but by the inherent dignity we are called to uphold in our laws and enforcement practices.
As your constituent, I respectfully urge you to:
- Support legislation to cease or sharply condition federal funding for ICE operations that have resulted in loss of innocent life and widespread civil unrest.
- Demand robust, independent investigations into the killings of Renée Good and Alex Pretti — including full release of video evidence and witness interviews — with accountability for any misuse of force.
- Advance policies that prioritize de-escalation, protection of civil liberties, and humane immigration enforcement — rather than militarized tactics that undermine community trust and safety.
- Use your oversight authority to ensure that federal law enforcement agencies are acting within constitutional boundaries and respect the rights of all U.S. citizens and residents.
Our nation is strongest when it protects life, upholds justice, and honors the dignity of every human being — principles cherished across faith traditions and rooted profoundly in Christian teaching about peace, justice, and love of neighbor. I urge you to reflect these values in your leadership and public policy decisions.
Thank you for your attention to this crucial matter. I look forward to your response and action.
Sincerely,
Rev. Dr. Steve West
Birmingham, Alabama